Mishap cut water service for thousands in Rockfish

By Catharin Shepard • Editor • Residents of Rockfish were left without water last week, then were under a boil water advisory, after an accident with a utility line left workers scrambling around the clock to fix the problem.

What caused the water line break, what can be done to permanently fix it, how the county responded – and ways it can improve its response to such emergencies in the future – were part of talks Monday night at the Hoke County Board of Commissioners meeting.

The issue was also hotly discussed on social media over the weekend, with hundreds of comments on community Facebook groups demanding action and accountability from elected officials.

The water line break happened while employees with Hoke Contracting, a part of J&K General Contractors, were working on Phase III of a utility expansion in the Rockfish area, according to Hoke County Utilities Director James McQueen.

McQueen, and Zahran Holt of Hoke Contracting spoke about what happened during the manager’s report at the commission meeting.

“Working in an area like that beside the road in a utility-dense area, is one of the most complicated and intense experiences in trying to get utilities to a new area. We have an experience here where the county inherited infrastructure from the Rockfish community that was installed 70-plus years ago,” he said.

To work around the existing lines, when they started the job, Holt moved out four weeks ahead of time and spent a month digging by hand to try and identify all the different utilities lines and “mesh what I knew, versus what was actually in the ground.”

“This particular instance, we were digging by hand, trying to locate this water line, and see what the connection was and what was exactly happening. During the excavation by hand, the thrust block started shifting. We could see that. And at that point, a short section of line blew out from under the road.”

The workers tried to fix it immediately with a gasket, but “there were so many cross-connected lines that were attached into the system, one of them was crimped.”

When the system was turned back on, the line infiltrated and softened the material and caused the thrust block to fail, Holt said.

“We stayed at it. We worked just as hard as we could at it with the county’s help. Everybody was just giving it 100 percent to get the water back to the citizens and the county,” he said. “We all live here, and we don’t want to cause these things. We did everything we could beforehand to prevent it, and it was just a terrible sequence of events. From this point on, we will still do everything we can to prevent it and just do our best possible job for the county.”

McQueen explained further what happened to cause the water line blowout.

“What they were doing is installing an actual force main. Installing the force main. They ran into an issue where there’s old infrastructure,” McQueen said.

The water lines in the area are made of concrete asbestos pipe, which is no longer used in construction. Modern pipelines use PVC or metal.

A piece of buried equipment called a thrust block, apparently shifted during the digging. The utilities director later explained what a thrust block is, and why the location of that particular part of infrastructure caused the line break to be both a bad scenario, and potentially difficult to permanently fix.

“A thrust block is almost like, you build a water line up to this point because you have nowhere else to take it. But because of the pressure on it, you need to have something behind it so it doesn’t blow out,” McQueen said after the meeting.

“When they were digging, the thrust block shifted. When it shifted, it actually removed itself from its job of holding the water back. When that happened, you’ve lost your ability to retain the pressure.”

In the area where the contractors were working, there’s an elevated tank that holds about a million gallons of water, which puts pressure on that section of pipe.

“That’s what that line comes off of,” McQueen said.

The break wasn’t something that could be permanently fixed overnight. Workers put in a temporary fix Thursday night, but water was off again Friday. Saturday, after service was restored, the county issued a boil water advisory for affected residents. Another notice about a water leak went out to residents Monday night, not long before the commission meeting.

The county has been seeking quotes for a long-term solution that will solve the problem once and for all, the utilities director said.

“If you can take and abandon the actual asbestos pipe under the road, and put an insertion valve in place – with that insertion valve in place, now you’re able to abandon that line under the road and basically, you don’t have to worry about it moving forward,” McQueen said.

The benefit to using that solution is that residents shouldn’t have to lose their water service to more downtime while the work is going on, he added.

“The whole key to it is not to turn the water off again. So, if you put in an insertion valve, you wouldn’t have to actually cut the water off from the actual customers. You could do it, what I consider live,” McQueen said. “Doing it live brings the cost up a little more, but that’s what we’re looking at right now.”

The county office is looking for other vendors that can provide information on the proposed solution.

“I’m a progressive thinker. My thought process is, let’s learn and find something good in it, and we’re going to move forward,” McQueen said to the county commissioners. “And let’s look at how we can be better, and let’s fix some of the issues that we currently have.”

One speaker, Ken Gregory of Rockfish, suggested that the county locate its valves to be better able to handle emergency water shutoffs. McQueen said that’s something the department already does, but it’s a big job.

“That’s something that we’ve already implemented, but we have limited staff to be able to do that. We have 510 miles of actual water lines that have numerous valves on those water lines, so it’s really difficult to do that. What we’ve been doing is working with our GIS system to be able to identify those valves,” he said.

Elected officials and staff alike agreed that one major challenge was navigating how to communicate correct information to the public about what was happening, while the people with the most up-do-date details were standing in water and covered in mud, still in the field trying to fix the problem.

“When this break took place on that Thursday, as one of the people mentioned, what we dealt with was the fact that my job now becomes public relations. Because what happens is my guys will give me a call, and they’ll tell me, we have a line that’s broken. In that process, now I go to my computer. Now I start looking at how we’re going to do updates and send out information…we’ve actually had a meeting today on how we can move forward on giving the county and all the citizens a better way forward to be able to give out notifications,” McQueen said.

He suggested downloading the utilities app available on the county’s system, as that’s one way the county can keep people informed of updates. The county also used its website and Facebook page to inform the public.

In regards to the boil water advisory, McQueen said that sediment in the water line was to be expected when the water was turned back on.

“There’s a rule that governs public water systems. When you issue a boil water advisory, what you’re saying is you have as a utility you have the option to do that or not do it. My determination is, when we got to the point where we were six to eight hours away, which was the second day, we actually issued a boil water advisory,” he said. “What that really means is we’re recommending you boil your water.”

The reason for that advisory is that when the water is turned back on, sediment in water lines is stirred up. The utility department then immediately began flushing fire hydrants in the affected areas to try and flush out the system, but that isn’t a fast process.

“We have four distribution people for a system that’s 510 miles long,” McQueen said.

If anyone is still having issues with discolored water, they should contact Hoke utilities, the director said.

Hoke Contracting’s parent company, J&K General Contractors, took to Facebook to issue an apology.

“We sincerely apologize for the inconvenience. Despite calling for locates to avoid any issues, some old, unmarked pipes were discovered that the county wasn’t previously aware of. We’ve since worked closely with the county to address and repair the problem, and steps have been taken to ensure this doesn’t happen again in the future,” the post from J&K General Contractors said. “We understand this situation has caused frustration and delays, and we truly appreciate your patience and understanding. Service should be restored very soon.”

County, community response

Many people took to social media to talk about how the water outage affected them and their families, and to vent frustrations about the problem.

Teri Holliday used Facebook to post a message directed toward the county commissioners, seeking help.

“My family and I have endured 15 hours without this essential resource and urgently require 5 gallons to meet our basic needs, including food preparation, cleaning, hydration, bathing, and toilet flushing. The prolonged absence of water is precipitating a health crisis. Can you devise a solution and identify a water pickup location?” Holliday wrote.

Stacey Campbell Gillis posted to the What’s Happening Hoke discussion group, addressing local elected officials, “…it’s past time that County officials respond to the County’s ongoing water crisis. Thousands of residents are without water, and our local government hasn’t responded to the crisis. Us, residents need answers. We need water. Hoke County deserve access to reliable essential services! Local officials and contractors must be held responsible for the County’s persistent water crisis and broken water infrastructure. This has been an ongoing issue for Hoke County over the past few years.”

A post from one person, Greg Johnson, said “Stuff happens. Get over it.” Johnson wrote in the Facebook discussion group that “Every time there’s the slightest inconvenience in Hoke County, some of y’all act like it’s the end of the world. First thing you do it hop online to complain,” he wrote, adding that “then somehow it’s the commissioners’ fault, J&K’s fault, the new developments’ fault, or all three.”

“If you can’t handle being without water for a short period, I don’t know what to tell you.”

Johnson’s post on the discussion group got over 100 comments, most disagreeing with him.

Members of the community jumped into action to respond to the water outage. Both volunteers, and county employees helped hand out water. Rockfish Fire Department, and Rockfish Elementary School both served as water pickup locations. After a resident suggested it, the county opened the James A. Leach Aquatic and Recreation Center (JALARC) to those without memberships, so people without water service could use the showers and toilets.

Commissioner Allen Thomas interacted with people in the discussion group, posting updates and locations of the water distributions. Thomas said during comments at the board meeting Monday night that he had heard one particular account that stood out to him

“One young lady who said that she had a newborn, and said that the only way to feed her newborn was by mixing water, clean water, with the Similac. I thought about her, because she said she went to Walmart and Food Lion, but there was no more bottled water there. Those things stick with us,” he said.

“Accidents do happen, we’re not going to be in the business of pointing fingers. We’re going to use this as a learning lesson.”

Several people from Rockfish spoke during the public input session of the meeting, both offering praise and criticism about what happened.

Speaker Ken Gregory addressed the board to raise concerns about the response to the water outage.

“Nothing was geared up before Saturday on water and what-not,” he said.

“It’s a stress on these people…they moved here to be in the country, and they don’t have any water to flush their toilets. So, I came up with the idea of having people come up there (to the fire department) with their own containers, so they could get water and take it home.”

The county should have more of a pre-planning effort to avoid situations like this, he noted, and operate water valves at least six times a year to make sure they’re working.

Gregory also said that as a firefighter, he was concerned about what would have happened if Rockfish had to respond to a fire. The trucks only had about 3,000 gallons of water on hand.

“The EOC should have notified the rest of the fire departments, look, water is down on Rockfish, so you guys need to be standing by for an emergency and help for that station,” he said. “I just feel there’s been a little bit of a failure on the contractor, because I don’t feel that they knew what they were doing.“

Rockfish resident Earlene Harper thanked the commissioners, especially Chairman James Leach and Vice Chairman Harry Southerland, and Commissioner Allen Thomas.

“You showed up in a time of crisis,” she said. “Thank you for being very active and proactive on your Facebook page, Allen Thomas.”

“Twenty-two hours, actually just a little over twenty-two hours, with no water for an entire section of the county. People truly began to panic. Thank you for helping and resolving the problem. Hopefully it will never happen again, but I’m sure that with this experience behind us, we’ve all learned some valuable lessons and will move forward for the betterment of the future,” Harper said.

One resident, who identified herself as Michelle EK of Rockfish, was escorted out of the meeting after making her comments on the matter. (See separate story, this issue.)

Saying thanks

Southerland thanked a long list of people who stepped up to address the crisis, including McQueen, the county manager, county maintenance department, James Tedder, EMS, Brian Marley, Andrew Jacobs, Kris Covington, Parks and Recreation and others.

“Everybody came together as a team to work on this. It was unforeseen, but when you got on it, you stayed on it. It was all hands on deck. All throughout the night, two or three o’clock in the morning, we were getting phone calls and updates about what’s going on and what you need,” Southerland said.

Southerland also recognized Harper and LaVerra Flowers-Cruz, and the Rockfish Fire Department.

“They went out on their own and began to give water, and protect and supply the community. That didn’t go unnoticed. Great job,” Southerland said. “That’s when a community comes together in a crisis. We don’t point fingers, let’s just fix the problem.”

“We were not there for any political reason, we were there to make sure that our citizens could get water back as quick as possible, and make sure they have clean water to drink,” Leach said.

Most of the commissioners went out to the site to see the progress on the repair, the chairman added.

Commissioner Tony Hunt, responding to a comment made during the meeting, clarified that James McQueen is the county’s utility director, and runs the utility department, which is the water and sewer. Hunt is an elected official and does not work full-time for the county. As elected commissioner, is chair of the utilities committee.

Hunt’s home, and Southerland’s home were affected by the water outage.

Southerland thanked Hoke Contracting for being partners with the county.

“Certainly, they stayed on the job, working just like we did, to get the problem resolved,” he said.

Thomas offered comments about the situation after public input.

“Number one, thank you for the county employees that worked all night long,” he said. “Of course, there were things that we could have done differently. But until you’ve seen these people covered in water, in mud, all night long, working, because they knew the level of desperation – I want to thank them publicly for what they’ve done.

He later also spoke to specifically thank McQueen and Edens.

“I know you probably had a lot of sleepless nights, and I know that’s probably an understatement, especially dealing with us,” he said.

“What you all did in purchasing all that water in such a short period of time and getting that handed out the same day, within hours, people don’t see the logistics of how difficult that is. To be able to get county workman to come in on their day off…the county manager was able to rally those staff because of how important this was. We had more people than we needed, which is a good problem to have.”

The board is looking forward to hearing from McQueen about proposals to prevent issues like this one in the future, the commissioner said. There are things the county needs to look at as an after-action, to see how it could have better handled the situation.

“We want to know what we can do to make sure this doesn’t happen again,” Thomas said. “I hear you’re already working diligently on that, and it sounds like it’s going to take a lot of money, if I’m hearing correctly, so please let us know what all we can do to help you with this effort.”

The Hoke County Board of Commissioners scheduled a meeting for April 28 at 10 a.m. to discuss utility matters.